Book Review: An Afghan Winter By Rajesh Talwar


History holds witness to the fact that in any war, the civilians die the most tragic and unheroic death in the name of collateral damage. And that, war, was never and will be the solution. Rajesh Talwar’s political thriller An Afghan Winter  has its story set with the war-troubled Afghanistan of 2007 as the backdrop and, a journalist of Indian origin Anzan Safri as the protagonist.


Afghanistan, a country leery of war, conspiracy, murder, and violence perhaps reached the pinnacle in 2007 as far as death, suicide bombings and opium production are concerned. Our man, Anzan, a Buddhist by religion, lands on Afghanistan just before the onset of winter only to discover that life has little or no value as the country is under constant threats of Taliban and Al-Queda militants or mujaheddin.

Anzan (meaning ‘quiet mountain’ in Tibetan) meets Zeenat, an Afghan-American expat and Michael, an officer of the US military group posted in Afghanistan. The latter two were in love with each other. The three of them became friends in a jiffy and, then, things began to roll quickly. Michael got murdered in a blast; someone planted a good number of grenades in his room.

Zeenat, devastated and heart-broken, fails to fathom the motive behind the murder. Officer Wendell, a detective from the US, appears on the scene to investigate and, Anzan, feels determined to find out the man behind the murder of his friend, Michael. As Anzan delves deeper playing the snooper, he unearths egregious facts potent enough to put his own life in mortal danger. Will he be able to save himself?

What Worked For Me

Rajesh has portrayed the picture of the Afghan settlements neatly. The multiethnic problems, discrimination between the different communities of the Afghan society; the Hazaras are looked down upon and despised by the upper classes, the Pushtuns consider themselves superior to others, the life and beliefs of the common men, the condition of the women- all are intertwined with the main storyline. War is always aided and abetted by several other immoral practices and, that has been depicted through the character of the German owner of a Development business, Kart Kainzner.

I liked the tidbits of Afghan history shared. A multilingual, multiracial country by itself, Afghanistan became a melting -pot in the truest sense at that time. The political chicanery played by some influential men among the squalor of the war and terrorism makes the readers rethink about the authenticity of what they read or watch in the media when countries are engaged in wars!

I also liked the realization that dawns upon Anzan at the end.

“Compassion. That was the key word. Compassion needed to be factored into any karma korrector.”



It’s Anzan who tells us the story, in the first person in a too simple and somewhat stilted language. His views on religion, relationships, violence, war, as well as on the cultural and political aspects, sometimes have slackened the pace of the story. A monotonous feeling creeps into the mind of the reader. I, myself, felt like omitting a few pages a couple of times. (I resisted the temptation, though) However, his is a realistic and likeable character who possesses a definite ideology on everything.

What Could Have Been Better

As the adage goes, too many cooks spoil the broth, too many leading characters often make a novel over-crowded. Besides the protagonist, the author has tried to pay equal attention to other characters as well. Eventually, the number of subplots have raised.
Moreover, from the narrative tone, it would not be difficult for a thriller/mystery aficionado to draw the conclusion well before the author is going to make it. At least, I was able to do that.

Final Verdict

If you like history, have the interest to know about the political, economical and social conditions of an exotically beautiful country that permeated violence at the time period depicted in the novel, you can go for this book. Also, you will garner a good knowledge over the Afghani gastronomical delights. Don’t expect a fast-paced, hot and happening thriller.

From my side, it’s 3/5


I won a review copy from The Tales Pensieve as part of Reviewers Programme. Register on #TTP for lots of #book fun and activities.


61 responses to “Book Review: An Afghan Winter By Rajesh Talwar

  1. A beautifully structured review, I am sure the book will be a marvel in itself. I hope I could get to read more of such books but time plays spoilsport too often…I even missed the Delhi book fair this time…

  2. This was well thought out, giving a nice review by you.
    I still remember the mystery of the death and the woman who solved the crime you wrote, Maniparna. It had great depth and details! A surprise, too.🙂

  3. Truly an honest review. The only series of books I have read on life in Afghanistan are the ones written by Khalid Hosineni. So thanks for sharing should pick this up next time

  4. A balanced review my friend, it is hard here in the West to get a fair and accurate picture of Afghan society and a look at the issues facing them from the inside. Any book that encourages understanding is a good thing.

  5. Neat review. Reminds me of the story of Susmita Banerjee, who went to Afghanistan after marrying an Afghan and later escaped from Afghanistan during Taliban regime, only to return again and get killed.

    • O yes, I actually was thinking of her while reading this book. I was in my 10th standard when she published her book, “Kabuliwalar Bangali Bou”. Maa first protested that I shouldn’t buy any new book as Madhyamik (same as ICSE) was around the corner. But, I bought and read it eventually.😀😀 I have that book in my small collection. Susmita Banerjee’s experience poRle tomar raage gaa jwala korbe… Taliban era ta je ki joghonyo… bhaba jayna…!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s