Book Review: Private India By Ashwin Sanghi & James Patterson

Ashwin Sanghi
, rightly known as the Dan Brown of India, has teamed up this time with internationally acclaimed author  James Patterson , introducing Patterson’s Private series to India.

Private India is the most hi-tech and reputed Indian private detective agency headed by the inimitable Santosh Wagh and it runs as a branch of ” Private Worldwide ” detective organization, the one and only of its kind. Santosh  is a tormented soul as an event from his past life keeps repeatedly coming back to him in the form of a nightmare. So, while not acting as the Private head, he succumbs to the inviting appeal of Johnnie Walker.

Santosh and his team, find themselves entangled in a series of murders where no clue is left by the serial killer who is on a spree to kill reputed and famous women apparently having no connection between themselves. The first victim, a doctor from Thailand,Kanya Jaiyen, is found dead in the bathroom of the hotel Marina Bay Plaza.  Initially being appointed by the Hotel authority, Private India arrives at the scene, but later the police also happily let them to carry on with the investigation provided that they will share every detail of the development with ACP Rupesh Desai.
The first murder is followed by that of journalist Bhavna Choksi, then pop-singer Priyanka Talati and school headmistress Elina Xavier and some others.
While Mubeen, Private India’s full-time medical examiner and forensic expert, discovers some astounding facts about the murderer  from some DNA samples, Hari, the tech-geek  of Private, brings himself under suspicion for his dubious activities. The presence of a yellow garrote used to strangle all the victims makes the murders all the more mysterious as to whether it’s done as part of some ritual of an ancient cult.

Besides being a classical Whodunit thriller, most of the characters in it are dual-faced. The different shades of the characters are revealed along with the turn of events. This has successfully evoked the desired effect for a point comes when the reader begins to suspect  almost everyone as the possible murderer. And the question that seems more haunting is  Why the killer is doing this ? what’s the motive ?

The story spreads over alleys of Mumbai, from the Colaba causeway to Dharavi , it portrays a picture of Mumbai less known to people. Apart from the main murder plot, there are several sub-plots which includes a threat of bomb blast from the ISI indulged Mujahidin group, the pseudo-religious gurus like Nimboo Baba and typical Mumbaiya don like Munna. All these sub-plots are woven more or less perfectly with the main plot, adding more thrill to it.

What I like most is that the characters of the detectives are portrayed here not in a supermanisque manner.They are vulnerable human beings and are prone to make mistakes. I personally like the character of Nisha Gandhe, assistant to Santosh Wagh. As a typical Sanghi book, there are some mythological references too which I think have been put quite aptly this time. The appearance of Jack Morgan, the founder and ultimate boss of ” Private Worldwide” is quite praiseworthy though the way he acts  while confronting Munna in a dance bar is rather filmy.

There are no negative points whatsoever except for a couple of minor loose ends which I would refrain myself  from mentioning. Though the ‘motive’ placed behind so many immaculate murders at the end has disappointed me a bit. ( Some say I nitpick a lot when it comes  reviewing a murder mystery or a thriller ). An absolutely engrossing read and a page-turner. I enjoyed reading Private India and finished it at one go over four mugs of coffee. Those who like thrillers are sure to enjoy the book.

From my side it’s 4/5

Reviewed by ManiparnaSenguptaMajumder

This review is a part of the biggest Book Review Program for Indian Bloggers. Participate now to get free books!

Top post on, the community of Indian Bloggers

57 responses to “Book Review: Private India By Ashwin Sanghi & James Patterson

  1. Thanks for the review… seems like a worthy read! Being scared of inviting the liability of reviewing a silly piece I rejected Blogadda’s mail but now seeing so many good reviews I ordered it on flipkart… sigh… :-/


  2. When I read Krishna key, then only I decided – I am not going to read another book by him – shameless brand endorsement, paramount of unreal writing,too filmy crafted dialogues – and now two writers? When I saw the book a days back – I was absolutely ridiculed by the fact that two writers join hands to write a thriller, I guess he is now borrowing the normal thriller template from international writers and applying it to an Indian setting. Seriously – I can not read this book.

    Kichhu mone korle na to? Honestly bollum.


  3. You know I loved the beginning, the buildup and everything. But once *cough* spoiler *cough* blank* happens at the end, it seemed rushed. Like there was soo much of a buildup for nothing!


  4. Suddenly I’m read only reviews of this book, and the more I read, the more I’m tempted to buy. This does seem to be a very intriguing kind of book. Is it fast-paced?


  5. I have read most of the books by Aswin. I was thinking of giving this book a miss specially I am kind a bored of Private series. But still, interesting review and the plot seems to have some meat.



  6. Nice one Maniparna, the statement about the detectives being not super human makes so much sense and it helps relating to it that much easier and sensible too :).. Sounds like a theme I would definitely be interested in 🙂


  7. Wow Mani a 4 on 5 makes the book a must read. The review is written really well (well as always) but the only thing I thought was is this book available only in India? anyway ill pick it up on my Dec visit then, but i will read it for sure.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s